Designer
The Mint's fifth Chief Engraver — author of the Trade Dollar, and of a cabinet of magnificent coins the country decided not to make.
William Barber engraved one coin the whole world handled — the silver Trade Dollar that sailed to China by the ton — and a string of dazzling experiments the United States ordered, admired, and then refused to mint. His decade as Chief Engraver is a story of one quiet success surrounded by a vault full of beautiful might-have-beens.
William Barber learned his trade the old way — at his father's elbow. He was born in London on May 2, 1807, and was taught engraving by his father, John Barber. His early years were spent cutting dies and decorating silver plate: the painstaking, miniature work of pressing fine detail into hard metal by hand.
In September 1852 he emigrated to the United States and settled near Boston, where he worked in the same line for about a decade. His skill eventually reached James B. Longacre — the man who had designed the Indian Head cent and the Liberty Head double eagle, and who was then Engraver of the Mint (the official who cuts the master dies a nation's coins are struck from). In 1865 Longacre hired Barber as his assistant in Philadelphia.
When Longacre died in early 1869, the top job was open. On January 20, 1869, President Andrew Johnson appointed Barber the fifth Chief Engraver of the United States Mint. He would hold the post for ten years, until his death — and almost at once he brought in his own son, Charles E. Barber, to work beside him. That single choice would shape the rest of his career, and the rivalry that ran through it.
Here is the strange shape of Barber's legacy: his most important coin was built to leave the country, and his most spectacular coins never left the Mint.
The coin that left was the Trade Dollar. After Congress authorized it in the Coinage Act of 1873, the Mint took up Barber's design — a seated Liberty perched on bales of merchandise, holding an olive branch, facing left toward the sea and Asia, with an eagle on the reverse — the obverse being the "heads" side, the reverse the "tails." It was a piece of deliberate commercial diplomacy. American silver interests wanted into the markets of China and the Far East, where merchants trusted the big, heavy Mexican silver dollar. So Barber's coin was built to beat that rival on metal: 420 grains of .900-fine silver, a touch heavier than a standard U.S. silver dollar. Millions crossed the Pacific. Chinese merchants stamped them with small chopmarks — punches that vouched for the silver — so a chopmarked Trade Dollar is, in effect, a coin wearing the signatures of the men who trusted it. It circulated for export from 1873 to 1878, then survived as a proof-only collectors' coin into the 1880s; the 1884 and 1885 proofs (ten and five known) are among the most storied rarities in American numismatics.
The coins that didn't leave the Mint are the patterns — a pattern being a trial coin, struck to test a design or an idea that may never reach production. The Mint kept ordering grand ones from Barber, and the country kept saying no:
Barber's style was clean, careful, and conservative — a die-sinker's precision more than a sculptor's drama. Auction cataloguers have been candid about it; one Heritage lot flatly calls his goloid dollar "rather bland." That is a fair read of the man. His gift was technical control of the die, not the bold relief later associated with the great American coin sculptors. He poured much of that control into medals, where it shone: the 1869 "Broken Column" medalet mourning Lincoln, the popular 1869 Pacific Railroad medal marking the transcontinental link (he personally handed the only gold example to President Grant that December), the 1876 Centennial medal, and Grant's second inaugural medal.
His decade also had a human grain of conflict running through it. In 1876, Mint Director Linderman hired a young English engraver, George T. Morgan, as an assistant — without consulting his own Chief Engraver, and with Morgan reporting straight to Linderman. The two Barbers, father and son, were cold to the newcomer; William wanted Charles to inherit the engraving department, and saw Morgan as a threat to that plan. Accounts say Barber told Morgan there was no office space for him, leaving Morgan to work from a rooming house until Linderman ordered room be made. In late 1877 Linderman set the two against each other in a design contest for a new silver dollar. Morgan's entry won — and became the Morgan dollar, the most collected U.S. silver dollar of all. The friction eased only when Linderman retired in 1878.
He worked nearly to the end. In the summer of 1879 he caught a severe chill bathing in the sea at Atlantic City, New Jersey. He died in Philadelphia on August 31, 1879, aged 72, and was buried at Mount Moriah Cemetery. His official cause of death was recorded as "debility" — plain physical exhaustion. Five months later, on January 20, 1880 — eleven years to the day after William's own appointment — Charles E. Barber got the job his father had wanted for him.
No words of William Barber's own seem to survive in the record. What survives is how the people he worked beside remembered him. At a staff meeting on September 2, 1879 — two days after he died — his Mint colleagues set down this tribute:
"In parting with him, we lose the co-operation of an affable, active, pain-staking, and meritorious officer, skilful in one of the most difficult of all arts."
(Memorial tribute recorded at the Philadelphia Mint after Barber's death. No primary statement by Barber himself has been located; any direct Barber quotation added later should be sourced before publishing.)
colcur earns a commission when you buy on eBay through our links — it never changes your price. Each listing opens on its original eBay marketplace.